The Canon 20D
|
Type |
Digital SLR |
Shutter Range |
1/8000 to 30 seconds |
Shutter Type |
Vertical Travel, Electronically Timed Focal Plane |
Meter Type |
CMOS |
Meter Range |
EV1 - EV20 |
Exposure System |
35 zone TTL |
Lens Mount |
Canon EF Autofocus |
Battery |
BP-511 |
Digital Specs
|
Sensor Type |
CMOS |
|
LCD Display |
1.8" - 118K |
Sensor Size |
22.5x15 mm |
Recording Media |
Compact Flash |
Sensor Resolution |
8.2 MP |
File Size |
3.6 - 8.7 MB |
Focal Length Compensation |
1.6 |
Film Speed Equiv. |
100 - 3200 |
The Canon 20D was introduced in 2004. It was the fourth generation
Canon "prosumer" model - part way between a consumer grade and a
professional grade camera. It was not until the 40D was introduced in
2007, that this camera was seriously improved upon. The intermediate model 30D was
a decent camera, but used the same imager, and had few improvements making it worth the upgrade.
As the 20D is over ten years old, and has been superseded by several
newer models, it is quite the photographic bargain these days. Costing
around $1500 new, as a used camera it can be picked up for a tenth that
price or even a bit less. I bought this camera used, and was quite
pleased.
Like all of the D series cameras, this is a semi-professional grade camera
with high resolution and the flexibility of the full range of Canon lenses.
Even so,
there are a number of features meant to appeal to the casual, or snapshot
photographer. So it is a camera that you can grow into. The autofocus feature comes to mind, as does the option for
fully programmed exposure. There is also a series of AE settings collectively
referred to as the Easy Shooting Zone. Each member of the series is pre
programmed to give good results taking the following types of shots:
- Portrait (Low Aperture, center spot metering)
- Landscape (High Aperture, averaging metering)
- Close up
- Sports (high shutter speed)
- Night scenes (Auto flash, combined with slow shutter speed)
- Flash off
The Creative Zone, is what Canon calls it's series
of more traditional, non programmed exposure modes. These modes are
- Manual exposure
- Aperture Priority
- Shutter Priority
- Automatic Depth of Field
Most photographers are familiar with how these types of auto exposure
work, with the exception of the strange Auto depth of field setting. This
setting checks all of the focus points, in the camera's viewfinder, and sets focus,
and aperture, so that they will all be in focus. Back in the old days, a
photographer would simply use a higher aperture, or perhaps stop down to
check depth of field. While this setting probably does the same thing,
it is better to know what you are doing .
The images are stored on Compact Flash media. Type I and type II are
supported, as well as fat 32, so that large cards may be used. The
images can be stored in three resolutions: large (3504x2336), medium
(2544x1696), or small (1728x1152), and two qualities: normal or fine.
This gives a total of six different image modes. The quality setting
determines the amount of compression that will be used to store the
image. Compression is a tricky thing. Though it does not technically
change the resolution, at high compression levels image quality suffers,
and "artifacts" of the compression algorithm can sometimes be noticed.
Images with many changes, and textures tend to suffer more from this
effect, than less complex compositions. For the real die hard, there is
the option to save the images in the RAW format, with no compression at
all. The RAW format is not just an uncompressed format. It saves the
images as the sensor sees them, by turning off a function of the
processor chip known as the Bayer Interpolation. You may be surprised at
how different your images look under RAW. I should mention that RAW
images can not be used in their native format, and must be processed
before display. Most viewers will not be able to open a RAW file, and
Canon includes a special program to do this.
The raw image file is 8.7 mb in size, compared to 3.6 for
large/fine, 1.8 for large/normal, 1.2 for small/fine, and .6 for
small/normal. A 1gb drive gives a capacity of 114 RAW photos, or 277 on
large/fine. On small/normal, you can fit 1062 shots per GB.
The heart of any digital camera is it's imager. The imager,
processor, and the
storage media combine to do the same job as the film of a conventional
camera. In the 20D, this is a small CMOS unit, developed by Canon for
still photography. The photographs taken with the 20D are rich, crisp,
and clear. Pictures may be viewed on the 1.8" 118K LCD on the back of
the camera. This is also where detailed settings and parameters may be
viewed are set. The LCD image is zoomable and panable.
I am, at heart, a manual shooter, and
rarely use any of the Creative Zone settings. The Manual setting
makes
this pretty simple. When set to manual, the dial on the camera back
controls the aperture, and the thumbwheel on the top of the grip
controls the shutter speed. Proper exposure, as determined by the camera
metering system, is displayed on a scale at the bottom of the
viewfinder, with a mark indicating how far the manual settings diverge
from the camera selected settings. Even better, the meter can be set for
center weighted, evaluative, or partial metering. When set to partial
metering, a small area (9%) is metered. This is wonderful for strongly
backlit or front lit scenes, and will work well, as long as the
photographer is aware, in any scene.
The photo to the right shows the top
of the 20D, with the mode dial to the left, and the thumbwheel control
and shutter release on the grip to the right. Also to the right is the
top mounted display. The display indicates the camera is in manual mode,
with settings of 1/60 of a second and F 8.0, as well as evaluative
metering, and single shot mode.
Sadly, as with all of the EOS
cameras, manual focus is difficult. Because these cameras (like all
current models) are so
dependant and oriented towards auto focus, there is no real provision
for manual, and the meter contains no focusing aids. So while the
autofocus can be turned off on the lens, it can be difficult to get a
precise focus manually, particularly in poorly lit scenes. The biggest
problem that most photographers have with autofocus is that it so often
picks the wrong focus points, and can sometimes be a bit slow. The 20D has a "joystick" toggle on
the back that can be used to select the desired focus point, of the nine
available in the viewfinder; but by the time you screw around with all
of this, compose and shoot, you could have more quickly just focused
yourself - if there had been a focusing aid in the viewfinder.
I also generally leave the
camera to AWB (Auto White Balance) for color rendition. There are a
number of parameter settings and filter settings you can use in this
camera; but I prefer to keep things simple. If I need to make any
changes, I do them post processing in Photoshop. I frankly don't like to
let the camera do too much of my thinking or adjusting for me. The whole
point of getting a really good camera is so that you can have full
creative control.
The left hand side of the camera has
buttons for setting the built in flash, and to stop the lens down for
depth of field preview. This is also where the lens release button is
located. Under a protective cover, it has connectors for video
out, digital, a remote control, and an old fashioned PC connector for
flash.
The Effect of
Film Speed on Image Quality of the 20D
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd824/dd824b9f72e8b1e043711306054c53b876c100e0" alt=""
|
A
tightly cropped photo of my desk at home in normal room light.
ASA 400 is to the far left, and ASA 1600 is to the right. For
comparison sake a shot at ASA 100 is just to the left. Though there
seems little difference between 100 and 400, the difference between
400 and 1600 is distinct. I usually shoot at 400.
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ffc77/ffc77b644c67d50d17f37e9b7229ad52c104a914" alt=""
|
The imager of the 20D is capable of operating at film speeds ranging from ASA
100 to ASA3200. The higher film speeds bring with them the traditional disadvantages
well known to generations of film photographers. Chief among these are
noise, and reduction of gray scale. In film cameras, this is produced by
the need for larger, more irregular grains of silver halide, needed to
work with smaller amounts of light. This tends to make the pictures grainier.
On digital cameras, noise is an artifact of the natural, random signals
given off by the sensor. These signals are generally below the threshold
of the signals produced by the light striking the face of the sensor, and
are overpowered by them. As the light intensity drops, these lower level
signals become noticeable. Another problem of operating at low light levels,
using fast speeds, is the problem of loss of contrast, and color saturation.
still, a higher ASA rating will get you a picture that might not be possible
with a lower setting.
The photo to the right shows the 20D
in clean mode, with its mirror up to allow access to the imager. The
imager itself is the small blue/green square visible at the rear of
the mirror box. The mirror itself is that slab of glass seen flipped
up on the roof of the mirror box. Also visible are the EOS
electrical contacts, towards the bottom of the lens mount.
|
If there is any real handicap to using a digital camera,
it is the constraint placed upon the digital photographer of always using
the same imager, no matter what the conditions or effect desired. The old time film
photographer had a distinct advantage here, because of the film camera's
capability of being loaded with any of a multitude of films being produced.
Film photographers have bulk loaded everything from commercial movie film
to 35 mm microfilm into their cameras. There is also a selection of special
purpose films such as Infra Red, High Contrast, and false color films.
One of the ways that digital cameras fight back, and get more
versatility, is by the use of film speed settings, and quality settings
(parameters can also be used, but I do not use them, or know enough
about them to really comment). This gives the user a bit of versatility,
though not to the degree of that enjoyed by the film photographer.
Still, the technology is moving along, and who can say what types of
imagers might be a few years down the road.
One thing for the owner of a DSLR to watch out for is dust on the imager. It's
going to happen, no matter how careful you are. Most cameras actually
leave the factory with some dust on the imager. And it is a dusty world.
Every time you change a lens, some dust gets in. Additionally, cameras
mechanicals wear against each other, creating dust. The problem is more
noticeable as you use higher apertures.
The Effect of Image
Quality Settings on the Canon 20D
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9207c/9207c29c151ed44d54bec462bcf56b580b89e39c" alt=""
High Quality
|
Enlarged sections of photos taken of the same subject, with the
same exposure, under the same conditions. Only the quality level is changed.
I always shoot at high. Memory is cheap. |
Average Quality
|
In addition to the film
speed setting, the 20D offers the option of three resolutions, and two quality
levels. The purpose of different levels of resolution is intuitively obvious.
The selection of quality levels is not really an artistic or an adaptive
control. The main function of the selection of quality levels is to give
the photographer some control over the file size of the images produced.
This is done by selecting between different levels of compression when the
images are being stored. In the 20D, images are generally stored in the JPEG
format, which is a compressed format. Compressed formats use algorithms to
look for patterns so that they can throw details away, and give smaller file
sizes. These same algorithms are used when the image is viewed, to reconstruct
the details that were taken out. Naturally, nothing conforms exactly to
any pattern or algorithm, and bits of the detail will not be reconstructed.
At higher compression levels, you get smaller files, but less accurate reconstruction
all the fine details. The more irregular, textured, or busy a scene is,
the more the compression effect will be noticed. The best candidates for
high compression are sunsets, and wide open vistas. The worst subjects for
high compression are diagrams, printed pages, or anything with a considerable
amount of detail or contrast.
|
The meter will set exposure down to EV 1,
at a rated sensitivity of ASA 100. With an f 1.4 lens, this is a 1 second
exposure. With the standard F 3.5 lens that comes with most kits, this
would be an 8 second exposure. The meter breaks the image up into 35 different zones of measurement.
This gives the capability of setting up a number of different metering patterns
for different
types of situations. This is what makes the Easy Shooting Zone settings
possible. So for landscapes, the metering pattern will be bottom weighted,
under the assumption that the upper portions of the frame will be filled
by the relatively bright sky. For portraits, semi spot metering will guarantee
that a face which fills the center of the composition, as is the case in
most portraits, will be perfectly exposed. For Close ups, center weighted
is just the thing. My favorite feature is a resurrection, of sorts, of the
old TTL semi spot metering of the old F series. When this option is chosen,
the EOS series does the old FD cameras one better by using a 9% circle,
as opposed to the FD 12% rectangle. This is the only metering setting that
I use.
The photographer has two ways to view his work. The first, and most
obvious, is through the viewfinder. As a reworked SLR, the 20D has a regular eye level, pentaprism viewfinder for through the
lens viewing via a ground glass screen. The eyepiece has a dial to give
up to 2 diopters of visual correction, for users who wear glasses. The
viewfinder itself displays the nine focusing marks (user selectable, of course), along
with shutter, aperture, flash, and autofocus information. There is also
a slightly shaded ring, which shows the metering area when semi spot metering
is selected. What is missing from the viewfinder, in this autofocus camera,
is any kind of focusing aid. This can make precise focus with a non autofocus
lens, rather difficult, particularly when using slow lenses.
The viewfinder is shown in the photo to the right.
Visible is the central circle which shows the metered area when using
partial metering. The nine focus points show up clearly, and flash red
when selected manually, to indicate the chosen focus point. The bottom
display shows the camera is set at 1/100 shutter speed, with an aperture
of F 10, and is at least two stops underexposed when compared to auto
exposure. The green dot far to the left indicates focus lock, and the
number nine shows that there is room for at least nine rapid fire shots
in the buffer.
To check photographs already taken, there is a built
in color LCD screen on the camera back. The screen can not be used to compose
or preview photographs, as it only displays what has already been stored
in the memory. The resolution of the 1.8", 118,000 pixel LCD is about half that
of a standard VGA monitor, and not too far inferior to that of the sensors
on cameras from just a decade ago. There is more to the LCD screen
than a fancy way to view your images. The images can be zoomed in on, and
the screen can also be used to view camera settings. On top of all of this,
Canon has included a way to display histograms, charts of color balance,
brightness, contrast etc., on this display. This is not a feature that I
use, preferring to view and adjust these levels in Photoshop (if at all),
but some users might find them convenient.
Two dials control most of the operations of the camera.
The dial to the left of the pentaprism, selects the shooting mode, while the
dial to the right sets the exposure. It is possible to use the camera,
while never touching another control, other than the power switch. For
those who enjoy a bit more creative control of their image, the 20D is able to
oblige. In addition to the easy Shooting Zone Settings, and the Creative
Zone settings, the camera has exposure compensation, and the option of setting
parameter definitions, which allow for customizing the color balance, brightness,
contrast, and intensity. Different sets of parameters can be defined
as sets, so that the demanding photographer can create a special parameter
set for indoor lighting, another for cloudy days, and still another for
bright sun.
Personal Observations:
This camera is very similar
to my old D30, and somewhat similar to my Digital Rebel. These are
substantial cameras, with metal frames, and sturdy bodies. They have the
full range of expected features, auto exposure and focus, a TTL system
for flash, various parameters and custom settings, a rear LCD for
instant photo viewing, and a built in flash. The 1/8000 top shutter
speed is the same as that on Canon's current models, and though higher
resolution cameras are available (I have several), the 8.2 MP resolution is
more than enough for most situations, and I use this camera often.
This was
the first model capable of taking the new EF-S type lenses. The lenses
are similar to the standard EF lenses, except that they have the rear
element closer to the film plane. They also focus to a smaller image.
They are more suited to the APS-C size sensor, and the image does not
need to cover the entire 35mm frame. The biggest advantage of the S
series of lenses is that they can be made somewhat smaller, lighter, and
less expensive. The disadvantage is that if you were to use such a lens
on a standard 35mm camera, the image would vignette, and not cover the
full frame.
The 20D shares the autofocus feature
of all of the EOS line, in common with almost every camera made these
days. It is very difficult to find a manual focus camera, and most
consumers have been brainwashed into believing this is a must have
feature. I have gotten used to autofocus; but never learned to like it.
Most photographers can do the job faster, and there are some situations,
notably low light, under which autofocus does not work. There is also a
problem, with certain compositions, of getting the camera to focus on
the right subject. There are options to set, the 20D has nine different
focus points, but the whole thing would really be much easier and faster
with manual focus. With autofocus being a standard feature these days, viewfinder
focusing aids have become a thing of the past, except for some expensive
aftermarket focus screens. The user has little choice but to rely on autofocus, stop
down, or settle for pictures which are somewhat unsharp. This is my biggest
complaint about the new generation of autofocus SLR cameras.
The 20D has a built in flash, which
pops up from the top of the pentaprism housing when the camera meter decides that it is needed.
The unit is fully integrated with the camera meter system, and has an ASA100
rating of 43. This is more convenient than I had first thought, and the
flash comes in very handy for snapshot type photography, and even more handy
as a fill flash for taking some of the contrast out of brightly lit scenes.
For the more demanding or flash dependent photographer, Canon offers a number
of very capable flash units which are able to fully integrate themselves
with the camera's metering, and focusing systems.
My best friends
on this camera, are the exposure hold button, and the manual override.
The exposure hold button is the easiest way to get by the computer
automation, or to photograph off center subjects, and still get a proper
exposure. It works best when the meter is set for 9% partial metering.
There is an exposure compensation system, for backlit, offset, or oddly
colored scenes, but I have never had good results with exposure
compensation; it takes too long, and requires too much guesswork. After
getting used to the system, I can now quickly set the aperture and
shutter speed after metering. I can then leave them while the camera
finds its focus. This is almost as fast as my old manual match needle
camera.
As with all of
the current crop of digital cameras, you can shoot all day (sometimes
all week) without changing the memory chip. Batteries are another
matter, and might only last for 1000 or so shots at the most; but
batteries are cheap, chargers are small, and spares can be brought. I
have never run out of memory without having run down my battery first.
In answer to this, Canon offers it's battery grip, which fits
seamlessly on the bottom of the camera, a
bit like a motor drive, and plugs into the battery compartment of the
camera. It holds two standard 2200 mah BP-511- batteries, or six
AA batteries of up to 2600 mah.
With the battery
grip, and the 8 GB memory card that I ordinarily use, this camera can
take approximately 2000 photos before recharging or using another card.
This should be enough for even the most insatiable photographer.
The camera comes with a battery, charger, USB cable, and AC adapter. The ac
adapter works by plugging into a receptacle on the charger. Once
connected, the adapter goes into the camera battery compartment. Canon
also offers a cigarette lighter adapter. There
is a radio controlled remote unit, and numerous flash options. The most
important accessory is the availability of the entire series of Canon EF
lenses.
This is a great camera, far nicer
than my original D30, that I got back in 2000, and quite a bit nicer
than my Rebel, though not quite as nice as my 50D. I suspect the 70 D is
even better, though as of this writing I have yet to get my hands on
one. Digital cameras continue to evolve, yet some of these older models
are still great picture taking tools, and are available at a fraction
of their original cost. The major limitation of this camera is its 8.2
MP sensor, yet plenty of weddings, nature shots, and magazine photos
have been taken with far less (3.2 MP on the 30D was used by many
professionals for years).
The resolution wars being engaged in by the
major camera manufacturers remind me a bit of the horsepower wars being
fought by the major auto makers back in the 60's/70's. In both cases we
are being offered capacities that we don't need and most of us will
never come near to using. The guy that bought the 500 HP muscle car back
in the late sixties, probably never drove it much past 60. The guy who
buys the top of the line 24 MP camera will probably never view his
photos at much more than the 1920 x 1080 (2 MP) resolution of today's HD
television, or the typical 1440 x 900 resolution of the average PC (1.3
MP). he will probably never print any photos at better than the standard
300 dpi standard.
For most photographers, under most
conditions, this is all the camera you will need. When compared to
Canon's latest offerings, the 20D will take all the same lenses,
including the newer EF-S type, has the same maximum 1/8000 shutter sped
of the latest models, as well as a sturdy metal frame, and costs a
fraction of the newest offerings. Unless you need the full 18 or 20
megapixels - why spend the money? |